Last updated: May 2, 2025
Best Organic Mattresses
Researched and Reviewed
Edited by: Lisa Libutti, Sleep Wellness Specialist
Published: May 1, 2025
Published: May 1, 2025
Looking for a healthier, non-toxic mattress? We got you.
Choosing an organic mattress means saying goodbye to harmful chemicals and synthetic materials. Whether you’re sensitive to off-gassing or just want a cleaner sleep environment, we’ve reviewed the best options for natural comfort, support, and sustainability.
Curated by Lisa Libutti, our Top-Rated Organic Mattress Review Collection highlights performance-based ratings and in-depth reviews by Judith Reynolds, Sleep Examiner’s dedicated sleep solutions specialist. We reviewed trusted sources, aggregated verified customer feedback, and scoured community forums to identify the best organic mattresses made without harmful chemicals or synthetic materials.
6 Recently Rated Certified Organic Mattresses
Performance Score: 7.2/10
Pros
- USA based company
- Fully certified organic
- Temperature regulation
- Affordable organic option
Cons
- Funky smell
- Tricky warranty & return policies
- Mixed reviews
- Not appropriate for sleepers 250lbs+
Performance Score: 7.9/10
Pros
- Eco-Friendly Materials
- Excellent Cooling Properties
- Strong Edge Support
- Generous Warranty & Service
Cons
- Motion Transfer Issues
- Firmness Not for Everyone
- Break-In Period and Return Fee
- Price Point
Performance Score: 7.6/10
Pros
- Customizable
- Great for hot sleepers
- Health-conscious
- Split option
Cons
- High price tag
- Limited sleep trial
- Edge support
- Cumbersome setup
Performance Score: 7.5/10
Pros
- Customizable
- Great for hot sleepers
- Health-conscious
- Split option
Cons
- High price tag
- Limited sleep trial
- Edge support
- Cumbersome setup
Performance Score: 7.3/10
Pros
- Great for hot sleepers
- Generous sleep trial & free white-glove delivery
- Comfortable “happy medium” feel
Cons
- Weak edge support for many
- Price Point
- Not ideal for side sleepers
- Hidden reviews suggest problems
Performance Score: 7.9/10
Pros
- Exceptional Comfort and Pressure Relief
- Cool Sleeping Experience
- Eco-Friendly Materials
- Responsive and Supportive
Cons
- Lacks Firmness for Some
- Edge Support
- Return Fee Frustration
- Delivery/Quality Issues
Want Your Mattress Reviewed?
… or Have One to Recommend? We’re always looking for quality sleep solutions to put to the test.
Contact us anytime.
We’d love to hear from you.
Whether you’re a brand looking for an honest review, someone seeking feedback on your current mattress, or a reader wanting to share your own experience, we’re listening.
📩 Email us at contact@sleepexaminer.com to:
- Request a review of your mattress brand
- Request a review of your sleep or wellness product
- Share your experience with a mattress we’ve reviewed
- Suggest a mattress you think we should test next
We’re listening… and always researching, so you don’t have to do all the legwork.
See More Recently Researched and Reviewed Mattresses
Nolah Natural Mattress Review
Crafted with certified organic latex, wool, and cotton, the Nolah Natural Mattress offers breathable comfort and medium-firm support. Designed for eco-conscious sleepers, it’s a hybrid bed-in-a-box that blends sustainability, bounce, and pressure relief.
Birch Natural Mattress Review
The Birch Natural Mattress by Helix blends GOTS-certified cotton, organic wool, and natural latex over pocketed coils for a breathable, eco-friendly sleep. We break down its performance across comfort, cooling, motion isolation, and more.
