Nolah Natural Mattress Review

How Did the Nolah Natural Mattress Perform? ?

Based on user reviews and trusted review sites.

Performance Score:

7.9/10

1. Are the materials truly certified organic? (Score: 8.5/10)

The Nolah Natural earns high marks for its use of GOTS-certified organic cotton and wool, as well as GOLS-certified Talalay latex, which are verified for sustainability and purity. Customers and experts alike praise the absence of synthetic foams or harmful chemicals, aligning with its eco-friendly promise. The recycled steel coils further bolster its green credentials, though some reviewers wish for clearer sourcing details on this component.

A few note that while the certifications are robust, not every element (like adhesives) is explicitly organic, keeping it just shy of a perfect score. Overall, it’s a standout for those prioritizing certified natural materials.

2. How is the overall comfort and support? (Score: 8/10)

Reviewers frequently describe the mattress as plush yet supportive, with its medium to medium-firm feel (~6/10 firmness) striking a balance that suits many sleepers, though some propose that it may feel more like a 7 on the scale. The Talalay latex layers contour gently to relieve pressure points, while the coils provide solid spinal alignment, earning widespread approval.

Side and back sleepers often call it a dream for comfort, but heavier individuals or strict stomach sleepers sometimes find it too soft for adequate support. Expert tests reinforce its quality, though it doesn’t cater perfectly to every body type. This versatility lands it a strong, but not flawless, rating.

3. Sleep Position Compatibility (Score: 7.5/10)

Side sleepers rave about the cushioning latex that cradles shoulders and hips, while back sleepers appreciate the lumbar support from the zoned coils. Combination sleepers enjoy the responsive bounce, making position changes effortless during the night.

However, stomach sleepers—particularly those over 200 pounds—report that the mattress can feel too soft, allowing hips to sink and misalign the spine. Reviews suggest it’s highly adaptable for most, but its medium firmness doesn’t fully satisfy all preferences, especially for those needing a firmer or softer surface. It’s a strong performer across positions, with a slight limitation for some.

4. How is the edge support? (Score: 7/10)

The HDMax™ Tri-Zone™ coils offer decent edge reinforcement, outperforming all-foam mattresses and allowing users to sleep or sit near the perimeter without major collapse. Customers note it’s sufficient for getting in and out of bed, but some feel a noticeable dip when sitting heavily on the edge. Compared to premium hybrids with reinforced perimeters, it falls short of exceptional stability, as reported in reviews like Mattress Clarity’s.

This could be due in part to the fact that Nolah Natural is compressed and rolled into a box for delivery, which can affect structure and aspects like edge support. Couples who maximize bed space find it adequate but not outstanding. This middling performance reflects a practical, if not top-tier, edge support experience.

5. How is the cooling? (Score: 8.5/10)

The mattress performs well at temperature regulation, thanks to breathable organic cotton, punctured Talalay latex, and an airy coil system that promotes airflow. Hot sleepers consistently praise its ability to stay cool, with NapLab awarding it a near-perfect rating for cooling in lab tests. Customers rarely report night sweats, a common complaint with foam-heavy beds, making it a favorite in warmer climates. The wool layer also wicks moisture effectively, enhancing the overall sleep environment. It’s a top performer in this category, with only minor quibbles from exceptionally heat-sensitive users.

6. Eco-friendly? How is the off-gassing? (Score: 9/10)

With organic certifications and natural materials like latex, cotton, and wool, the mattress earns high eco-friendly praise from green-minded buyers. Most users report no off-gassing—unboxing reveals little to no odor, a stark contrast to synthetic mattresses. The use of recycled steel coils adds to its sustainability profile, though some customers wish the shipping packaging (plastic wrap) were more biodegradable. Reviews occasionally mention a faint natural latex scent, but it dissipates quickly and isn’t chemical-based. It’s a near-perfect choice for eco-conscious sleepers with minimal environmental drawbacks.

7. Does it have good motion isolation? (Score: 7.5/10)

The individually wrapped coils do an admirable job of minimizing motion transfer, a plus for couples with restless partners. Customers note that movements like rolling over or getting up are less disruptive compared to traditional innersprings, aligning with expert tests showing solid isolation. Sensitive sleepers occasionally feel slight vibrations, particularly near the edges, but it’s rarely a dealbreaker.

Compared to all-foam beds, it’s not the absolute best at isolation, but it exceeds many hybrids. It’s a great pick for amorously active couples who will appreciate the traditional bounce provided by the coil layer, as confirmed by NapLab who gave it a “Best For Sex” award. This makes it a reliable pick for shared beds with a few minor caveats.

8. Warranty (Score: 8/10)

The limited lifetime warranty is a standout feature, offering free replacements in years 1-2 and prorated coverage thereafter (50% cost after year 10, 60% after 25 years), which gives buyers peace of mind about long-term durability. Customers value this protection against defects like sagging over 1.5 inches, seeing it as a sign of Nolah’s confidence in the mattress’s quality.

However, the $99 shipping fees for repairs or replacements after year 2 annoy some, especially since competitors often cover these costs. Additionally, the strict definition of “defects” excludes cosmetic issues like loose threads or minor cover wear, which can frustrate users expecting broader coverage. Despite these drawbacks, it’s a robust warranty that enhances the mattress’s value, earning it a strong rating.

9. Sleep Trial (Score: 7/10)

Nolah provides a 120-night sleep trial, giving buyers ample time to test the mattress at home, which is longer than the industry standard of 100 nights but shorter than the 365 offered by some competitors. Users appreciate the flexibility to ensure it’s the right fit, especially given its medium-firm feel.

However, the $99 return fee (deducted from the refund) draws consistent criticism, particularly when competitors offer free returns. This cost can deter some from returning, even if unsatisfied, lowering its appeal slightly. It’s a decent trial period, but the fee and overall length keep it from being top-tier.

10. Customer service & trusted ratings (Score: 7.5/10)

Nolah Sleep holds an A+ BBB rating (despite not being accredited), reflecting good business practices and responsiveness to the five complaints filed in three years. Customer reviews on platforms like Amazon and Google average around 4.5/5, with praise for comfort and eco-friendliness tempered by occasional gripes about delivery delays or return hassles.

Expert reviews are strong—NapLab places it in the top 4% of mattresses tested, and sites like Sleepopolis award it high marks. Some dissatisfaction with firmness expectations or customer service response times pulls it back from a higher score. Overall, it’s well-regarded with room for minor improvement.

A Closer Look at the Nolah Natural Organic Mattress Materials

The Nolah Natural is an 11” tall mattress, designed with a combination of eco-friendly materials to provide comfort, support, and breathability. Each mattress is assembled and shipped from Nolah’s Arizona based factory. This is a bed-in-a-box, so you’ll need to give it a few hours after setting it up to decompress.

Let’s take a look at the materials and role of each layer:

Top Cover: Organic Cotton

Made from organic cotton, which is grown without synthetic pesticides, insecticides, or GMOs, this breathable and soft cover serves as the outermost layer, providing a plush, comfortable sleep surface. It wicks moisture away from the body, helping to regulate temperature, and adds a durable, eco-friendly protective layer to the mattress.

Fire Barrier Layer: Organic Wool

A thin layer of GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) certified organic wool acts as a natural fire retardant, meeting federal flammability standards without the use of harmful chemicals or fiberglass. It also enhances breathability, wicks moisture, and contributes to temperature regulation, keeping the sleeper cool and comfortable.

Comfort Layer: Organic Talalay Latex (2 inches)

2 inches of hole-punctured, GOLS (Global Organic Latex Standard) certified organic Talalay latex provides responsive cushioning and pressure relief. The Talalay latex gently contours to the body’s curves, redistributing weight to alleviate tension around sensitive joints like the shoulders and hips. Its punctured design increases airflow for a cooler sleep experience, and its natural bounce ensures quick responsiveness to movement.

Transition Layer: Organic Talalay Latex (1 inch)

1 inch of organic Talalay latex acts as a transition between the softer comfort layer and the firmer support core below. It adds extra cushioning while maintaining responsiveness and durability, helping to ease the sleeper into the supportive coil system. It also contributes to the mattress’s overall breathability.

Support Core: HDMax™ Tri-Zone™ Coils (8 inches)

8 inches of individually-wrapped, recycled steel coils divided into three zones provides the primary support structure of the mattress. The Tri-Zone™ design offers targeted support—firmer in the lumbar region for spinal alignment and slightly softer under the shoulders and legs for pressure relief. The coils enhance durability, promote airflow for cooling, and reduce motion transfer, making it suitable for couples. The use of recycled steel adds an eco-friendly element.

Base Layer: Organic Cotton and Wool Foundation

A thin layer combining organic cotton and wool stabilizes the mattress, supporting the coils above and increasing overall durability. It reinforces the structure while maintaining the mattress’s natural, hypoallergenic properties and adding a final touch of breathability.

Our Analysis

The Nolah Natural Mattress emerges as a clever contender in the ever-expanding organic sleep market, deftly weaving organic cotton, wool, Talalay latex, and zoned coils into a package that’s hard to fault. It delivers a cool, responsive embrace that side and back sleepers adore, with eco-friendly credentials and a supportive core that promise years of restful nights—all at a price that undercuts many latex rivals. Customer praise for its comfort and minimal off-gassing, paired with Nolah’s wildlife-supporting ethos, paints a picture of a mattress that’s as virtuous as it is practical.

Yet, one can’t help but squint at the hype: can it truly satisfy every sleeper—stomach snoozers included—without a hitch, or is the $99 return fee a quiet hint that not all will find their perfect match? It’s a standout choice that feels almost too polished to be flawless, leaving you to wonder if the dream is as seamless as it seems.

Not every body type is compatible with Nolah’s 11” profile, and not everyone will love the firmness level some say is firmer than advertised, even after a year or two of ownership. And with so many awards and praise from huge companies that tend to receive financial compensation for said praise, is the Nolah Natural naturally amazing, or is the hype inflated?

Customer Insights

The Nolah Natural Mattress earns enthusiastic applause from customers who revel in its standout qualities, painting it as a near-ideal sleep solution for specific needs. Side and back sleepers, especially those under 230 pounds, laud its plush latex and supportive zoned coils, which deliver a cool, pressure-relieving embrace that rivals stuffier foam beds.

Eco-conscious buyers cheer the organic cotton, wool, and latex—certified and odor-free—while couples note the impressive motion isolation that keeps restless nights at bay. Early durability reports glow with optimism, suggesting this mattress could be a long-term companion, especially with its lifetime warranty in tow.

Yet, the feedback isn’t a unanimous love letter, as average experiences reveal a more tempered reality. Many find the medium firmness comfortable but not transformative, with some adjusting to its lively bounce or wrestling its hefty frame into place during setup. Cooling wins praise, though it’s not a miracle for the hottest nights, and the price—$1,364 for a Queen after discounts—feels fair but not a steal, particularly with a $99 return fee shadowing the trial.

The harshest critics, though less common, highlight flaws: stomach sleepers lament sinking hips, edge-sitters find the perimeter weak, and delivery hiccups or slow service frustrate some. That return fee amplifies discontent for the unsatisfied. It’s a strong choice for eco-minded hot sleepers and couples, but its limits keep it shy of flawless. Dissatisfied customers emphasize just how dissatisfied they are by insisting that the Nolah Natural Mattress is the “worst bed ever,” a note to be taken into consideration but not something that should necessarily halt the interested buyer.

The Final Verdict: 3.8/5

Eco Warriors: Approach With Cautious Optimism

The Nolah Natural Mattress struts onto the bed-in-a-box scene with a compelling pitch: organic materials, cool sleep, and a supportive hug that side and back sleepers can’t stop praising. Its blend of Talalay latex, zoned coils, and eco-friendly fabrics delivers a responsive, breathable bed that feels like a smart splurge for the green-minded and restless-partnered alike. Early signs point to lasting quality, bolstered by a warranty that whispers confidence.

Still, it’s not a universal crowd-pleaser—stomach sleepers might grumble about sinking hips, and edge-sitters could find the perimeter a tad wobbly. The price, even discounted, asks for a calculated leap, and that return fee looms as a quiet nudge to commit. It’s a solid performer, but you’ll want to weigh your sleep style against its quirks.

In the end, this mattress lands as a savvy pick for a specific crew: those craving cool, natural comfort with a conscience. It’s got plenty to offer, yet a hint of skepticism lingers—can it truly deliver for everyone, or is it a niche gem dressed as a do-all? Approach with eyes open, and it might just earn its spot in your bedroom.