Judith Reynolds, Sleep Solutions Specialist
The Perfect Mattress For Eco-Conscious Families and budget shoppers?
Our Review and Analysis
If you’re an American looking to support your health and your country, the mattress you choose matters — after all, you spend a third of your life resting on it. Is it made in America with sustainably sourced materials? Is the company transparent, responsible, and highly certified? If you’re asking yourself these questions while on the hunt for a mattress that not only cradles you into dreamland but also keeps your conscience clear, you may be interested in the Avocado Eco Organic Mattress. With multiple environment based certifications that Mother Earth herself would approve of, Avocado promises a mattress made in Los Angeles, CA with responsibly sourced and sustainable components.
At a medium firmness that fits most, Avocado uses all the right words to reel in eco-conscious families and budget-minded shoppers looking to get back to nature with their Eco Organic Mattress. But will Avocado make or break these promises? Instead of opening a dozen tabs to find out, I’ve gathered all the key details here to help you decide.
Our Review Process: At Sleep Examiner, we’re passionate about natural ways to reduce stress, relax the body, breathe better, and improve sleep quality. Our commitment to providing well-rounded, unbiased perspectives ensures that every recommendation is thoroughly researched, helping you discover the practices, products, and tools that can lead to a restful, pain-free night’s sleep. We’ve recently updated our 5 best mattresses for back pain and joint relief, ensuring you have the best options for enhanced comfort and support.
Avocado Eco Organic Mattress Rating
-
1. Certified Organic Materials - 8.5/10
8.5/10
-
2. Comfort & Support - 7.5/10
7.5/10
-
3. Sleeping Position Compatibility - 7/10
7/10
-
4. Edge Support - 7/10
7/10
-
5. Cooling & Breathability - 7.5/10
7.5/10
-
6. Eco-Friendliness & Off-Gassing - 7/10
7/10
-
7. Motion Transfer & Motion-Isolation - 7/10
7/10
-
8. Warranty - 7/10
7/10
-
9. Sleep Trial - 7/10
7/10
-
10. Customer & Trusted Ratings - 6.5/10
6.5/10
Summary
Performance Score
PRODUCT DETAILS
GOTS-certified cotton and wool cover, GOLS-certified latex, recycled steel coils, and OEKO-TEX certified.
100 night trial period with 1 month minimum adjustment period, limited to 1 mattress per household
Free Shipping with surcharge to AK & HI, $99 return fee, local pickup available to CA residents
Exclusively medium firmness, about 5.5/10
10 year warranty, voided by what Avocado considers misuse
$1,199-$1,699
PERFOMANCE SCORE
How did the Avocado Eco Organic Mattress perform?
Based on user reviews and trusted review sites.
Performance Score: 7.2/10
1. Are the materials truly certified organic? (Score: 8.5/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic Mattress is crafted with sustainability in mind, featuring GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex, GOTS-certified organic cotton, and wool that’s both GOTS-certified and sourced from the Himalayas under the Responsible Wool Standard. Said wool is also anti-microbial, resistant to dust mites, and offers natural temperature regulation. The core includes recycled steel coils for durability and support. Avocado uses exemplary practices in transparency and certification, boasting a long list of certifications (including GreenGuard) and ensuring materials are ethically sourced and eco-friendly, with a clear commitment to sustainability and social responsibility guaranteeing a fully lab-tested organic mattress.
2. How is the overall comfort and support? (Score: 7.5/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic mattress features a medium firmness, landing at a 5.5 out of 10, which provides a balanced feel for many but might not suit heavier or strict back sleepers seeking firmer support. The inner coil system provides a bounce couples may appreciate during intimacy. Offering a cozy yet not overly plush sleeping experience, Avocado’s Eco Organic mattress offers a hug that is more traditional and generalized around the body, something not everyone may love.
3. Sleeping Position Compatibility (Score: 7/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic mattress, with its medium firmness and 10-inch profile, strikes a balance that could be particularly appealing to side and stomach sleepers seeking a plush yet supportive sleep surface. Its design offers comfort where it counts, contouring to the body without sacrificing the necessary support. However, if you’re a heavier sleeper or someone who prefers a firmer mattress for back sleeping, you might find it feels a tad too soft for optimal spinal alignment. Some reviewers reported feeling a little more sag in the middle than they would’ve liked.
4. How is the edge support? (Score: 7/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic mattress offers decent edge support, but some reviewers have noted it as less than ideal, particularly for those with heavier body types or who prefer sleeping near the edge. This might be linked to the mattress’s 10-inch height, which lacks specific edge reinforcement, potentially leading to more sagging than some might prefer. Keep this in mind if you use the edge of your bed for more than just sleeping; there may be some slippage when rolling out of bed, as well.
5. How is the cooling? (Score: 7.5/10)
An initial layer of open-cell latex enhances this mattress’s ability to avoid heat retention, offering a comfortable sleep environment regardless of the season that adapts to your movement as well as temperature. Thanks to its thoughtful construction that also includes organic wool and cotton, The Avocado Eco Organic mattress offers impressive cooling and breathability. These materials are adept at wicking away moisture, keeping you dry throughout the night. This design ensures warm winters and cool summers, a feature that numerous reviewers have experienced and praised.
6. Eco-friendly? How is the off-gassing? (Score: 7/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic mattress prides itself on eco-friendliness with its use of organic and natural materials, but the conversation around off-gassing is mixed. Organic materials like those used by Avocado can often smell earthy, a funky odor that not everyone will love. While Avocado and numerous reviewers claim that the initial barnyard-like odor should naturally dissipate within a few days if the room is well-ventilated, some customers have reported a more persistent smell. This has led a few to question the quality of the materials used, with some even opting to return their mattresses due to the lingering scent. This experience highlights the variability in individual sensitivity to odors and the importance of considering personal comfort when it comes to eco-conscious products.
7. Does it have good motion isolation? (Score: 7/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic mattress strikes a balance between bounce and calm. With an 8-inch layer of coils, it offers that familiar, lively feel of a traditional mattress, providing bounce that some sleepers love. However, the 2-inch layer of open-cell latex on top works to dampen this motion, offering a degree of motion isolation. While this setup manages to mute a significant amount of movement, couples with partners who are restless might find that the mattress doesn’t completely eliminate disturbances. If you’re in that camp, you might consider a mattress with denser foam for even better motion isolation.
8. Warranty (Score: 7/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic mattress comes with a 10-year limited warranty, which, while substantial, doesn’t quite match up to the lifetime warranties offered by some competitors. This warranty covers defects in material and workmanship, but there’s a fair amount of fine print to navigate. It’s non-transferable and applies only to the original purchaser from Avocado or an authorized reseller. Key stipulations include that visible indentations must be at least 1.5 inches (or 0.75 inches for crib mattresses) not resulting from improper support. The mattress must be used with an appropriate bed frame or foundation, rotated regularly, and the warranty could be void if these conditions aren’t met. The process for a warranty claim involves providing proof of purchase and photos, along with detailed documentation of the defect and the mattress’s condition. While Avocado offers a comprehensive warranty, it’s crucial to understand these conditions to ensure coverage when needed.
9. Sleep Trial (Score: 7/10)
The Avocado Eco Organic mattress offers a 100-night sleep trial, providing a decent window to decide if it’s the right bed for you, though it doesn’t match the year-long trial some competitors offer. There’s a one-month minimum adjustment period before you can initiate a return, acknowledging that it takes time for your body to adapt. However, be aware of the stipulations: using the mattress on an improper foundation or not rotating it as recommended can void your trial. Also, the mattress must be opened within 30 days of receipt, and it should be in donatable condition, free from stains or damage, for you to be eligible for a return. Finally, this only applies to one mattress per household, so if you’re thinking of getting multiples, use caution.
10. Customer and Trusted Ratings (Score: 6.5/10)
It’s important to remember that a brief search of any mattress from a well-built brand will likely pull up stellar reviews and praise from paid influencers and writers alike, so extended research is always recommended. Digging deeper, there seems to be a darker side to the mattress’s reputation, with some customers sharing nightmarish experiences. These include issues like unexpected sagging, firmness or discomfort leading to body pain, and in extreme cases, concerns over the mattress’s durability or materials not living up to the promised expectations. Other criticisms around the web touch on aspects like the stench of the materials, poor experience with the company and its support, and the mattress feeling too firm for some, particularly side sleepers. These points should be considered, although individual experiences vary greatly depending on one’s body type and sleep preferences. Potential buyers might want to take these reviews with a grain of salt, understanding that the mattress might not be the perfect fit for everyone and no company is perfect.
A CLOSER LOOK
Closer Look at the Avocado Eco Organic Mattress Materials
This is a 10” thick mattress with two main layers and a cover. Let’s take a closer look:
Cover
The Avocado Eco Organic Mattress is encased in a cover made from GOTS-certified organic cotton, offering a soft, breathable surface that’s gentle against the skin. This eco-friendly choice not only feels luxurious but also aligns with the mattress’s commitment to sustainability.
Wool Layer
Beneath the cover lies a layer of GOTS-certified organic wool from the Himalayas, adhering to the Responsible Wool Standard. This wool layer not only adds to the mattress’s natural fire resistance but also enhances breathability, helping regulate temperature for a cooler sleep experience.
Latex Layer
The next layer consists of 2” of GOLS-certified organic open-cell Dunlop latex, providing a responsive yet supportive feel. Known for its durability and resilience, this latex layer offers natural bounce and comfort, contributing to the mattress’s overall medium-firm support profile.
Coil System
At the core of the mattress, you’ll find individually fabric encased recycled steel coils. This system offers a traditional bouncy experience and is designed to promote airflow, offering good support and alignment. These 8” coils flex independently, and when combined with the latex layer, provide a hybrid experience with minimal motion transfer.
Edge Support
The pocketed coil base and comfort latex layer offer decent edge support for those with a light to medium build (under 200lbs). However, some users have noted that this edge support might be a little lacking compared to other mattresses in its class, potentially leading to less stability when sitting or sleeping near the mattress’s perimeter.
PROS & CONS
Based on user reviews, here’s a list of the pros and cons of the Avocado Eco Organic Mattress:
PROS:
USA based company: Those looking for an American company may appreciate that Avocado’s factory is located in California, where they use domestic and imported materials from co-owned farms, aiming to make something organic that’s better for you and the planet. Their 175,000 sq ft factory in LA is certified by Control Union to manufacture materials under the Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS).
Fully certified organic: Avocado proudly displays numerous certifications and rigorous testing to ensure that their mattresses have earned their organic title, something other brands do not go the distance to achieve, only using “organic” as a buzzword and element in their competing mattresses. The Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) and GOLS are standards that “define worldwide recognized requirements that certify the organic status of textiles and latex, from harvesting the raw materials through environmentally and socially responsible manufacturing,” according to Avocado’s website.
Temperature regulation: The construction of the Avocado Eco Organic mattress includes open-cell latex, innerspring coils, organic cotton and wool that naturally regulate temperature and encourage airflow. This aspect is rarely if ever complained about, and testers have concluded that the mattress does a fair job at meeting these expectations.
Affordable Organic Option: Compared to other brands that offer an organic mattress, Avocado’s Eco Organic model is relatively affordable, especially if you can catch a good holiday sale. Considering this is a hybrid mattress from an eco-friendly brand, the fact that none of the mattress sizes range above $1,800 is a plus.
CONS:
Funky smell may be a turn off: The use of organic materials often comes with an earthy smell that some customers have said still comes across as a chemical odor they can’t stand. While this odor should dissipate in less than a week with some ventilation, it could still linger, which may be a dealbreaker for those with highly sensitive noses. On the other hand, this could be an acquired smell loved by farm-owners and crunchy moms alike.
Tricky warranty & return policies: The fine print in Avocado’s warranty is a bit of a red flag. There’s a fair amount of stipulations in a warranty that is shorter than competing companies, and if Avocado decides that you haven’t treated your Eco Organic with the utmost respect they demand, they could turn down your request for a return or replacement. Some customers have reported that this warranty is just too strict, leaving them feeling cheated.
Mixed reviews: Beyond the standard (and likely paid) five star reviews, there are some downright awful reviews of the Avocado Eco Organic Mattress that browsers should certainly take into consideration. Complaints range from the firmness not meeting expectations, to lengthy delays in delivery, to terrible experiences with the company’s customer service team. Some customers report early sagging in their mattress that left them disappointed.
Not appropriate for sleepers 250lbs+: If you’re not a light to medium build, the Avocado Eco Organic Mattress may not be right for you. The 10 inches of mattress is a standard height with a simple build that likely won’t provide enough support for heavier bodies, who will experience more sagging in the middle of the mattress. Couples with a higher combined weight should also beware, as this could affect their shared experience and motion transfer.
FINAL SLEEP RATING ANALYSIS
Our Analysis
For the environmentally concerned patriot, the Avocado Eco Organic mattress has a lot of attractive qualities. From a friendly medium firmness that appeals to a wide range of sleepers, this is a simple yet affordable mattress considering its rigorous testing and thoroughly certified organic materials.
However, most recent and popular lists of “Top 10 Organic Non-Toxic Mattresses to Own” don’t include the Avocado Eco Organic mattress, indicating that this could either be a flop or a hidden gem. Organic mattresses are a niche product, designed with eco-warriors in mind who may have sensitivities to materials in the average mattress from companies that use polyurethane foam, chemical flame retardants and fiberglass in their products.
That being said, this mattress is aimed at a pretty specific audience. If you’re looking for an American based company that uses sustainability and responsibly sourced organic materials, supports farming, offers vegan options, and keeps the price below $2,000, you’re in luck with Avocado. Even if the Eco Organic model doesn’t quite do it for you, Avocado has several other options with slightly different builds, sleep trials and materials that are dialed in to your needs and expectations from an organic mattress.
Customer Insights
Positive reviews speak highly of the Avocado Eco Organic’s comfort, cooling properties, support and longevity. Many customers are impressed by how affordable the mattress is considering the lengths Avocado has gone to to ensure a fully organic mattress that will last. Weak points mentioned are the motion transfer and edge support, meaning you may feel your partner or pets moving around and might not want to sleep too close to the edge. Overall, lovers of the Avocado Eco Organic mattress state that it’s easy to move around on, breathable and supportive for combination sleepers.
As previously mentioned, there are some utterly devastating reviews of this company if you know where to look. A few customers report early sagging of their Avocado within the first few months, discomfort that never improved, an unattractive and stubborn scent, as well as some very concerning difficulties with initial delivery and terrible customer service experiences in which Avocado either ignored or denied requests for returns or replacements. Potential buyers may also be interested in the fact that Avocado was sued in 2023 for false advertising, though the lawsuit was consequently dropped the same year. Buying a mattress is a major decision, so be sure to consider the good, the bad and the ugly before making a commitment.
The Final Verdict: 6.5/10
The Avocado Eco Organic: A Green Choice with Mixed Reviews
The Avocado Eco Organic Mattress is both a beacon for eco-conscious consumers and a source of mixed experiences. Crafted by an American-based company, this mattress reflects a commitment to sustainable living, featuring GOLS-certified latex and GOTS-certified cotton and wool, all responsibly sourced. Its medium firmness is often praised for providing a balanced feel that supports without being too soft or too firm.
However, it’s not a perfect fit for everyone. Some customers have reported delivery delays and issues with edge support and motion isolation. Heavier individuals might find the support lacking, and those preferring a softer or firmer bed may need to explore other options.
While it’s a strong choice for those seeking an eco-friendly, organic mattress with balanced firmness, prospective buyers should consider their specific sleep needs and body type before deciding. The materials and certifications are impressive, but the overall performance may not meet everyone’s expectations.
Judith Reynolds, Sleep Solutions Specialist
MATTRESS SIZES & PRICES
(price may not include discount or sale items)
| SIZE | DIMENSIONS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|
| Twin | 75" x 38" | $777 |
| Twin XL | 80" x 38" | $899 |
| Full | 75" x 54" | $1,199 |
| Queen | 80" x 60" | $1,299 |
| King | 80" x 76" | $1,699 |
| California King | 80" x 72" | $1,699 |
PRODUCT WARRANTY & VALUE
Avocado Eco Organic Mattress Warranty
The Avocado Eco Organic Mattress comes with a 10-year limited warranty that covers defects in material and workmanship. Here are the main points, stipulations, and considerations:
The warranty applies to the original purchaser only and is not transferable. It includes visible indentations greater than 1.5 inches (or 0.75 inches for the Eco Organic Crib Mattress) that are not due to an unsupportive foundation.
The warranty begins from the date of purchase and requires the mattress to be unpackaged and used on a supportive foundation as specified by Avocado.
Avocado states that the mattress must be regularly rotated for even wear, and any warranty claim must include photographic evidence of the defect, original proof of purchase, and the law tag showing the mattress serial number.
Normal wear and tear, stains, improper use, or use with an inadequate bed base are not covered. Size discrepancies must be reported within the trial period. If a defect is confirmed, Avocado may replace or repair the mattress at their discretion, a key phrase to remember, since some customers have reported being snubbed by the company. In case of replacement, you might be asked to donate the old mattress to charity, providing proof before receiving a new one.
You may need to shell out shipping costs of around $99 to return your mattress.
Considerations: Using a solid base (no slats) and a mattress protector will help keep your mattress in top condition for warranty claims. The warranty does not cover changes in comfort preference over time but focuses on defects in construction.
Learn more about Avocado’s warranty here.
Check out our Top 5 Mattresses for Back Pain
For an in-depth look at our top picks, complete with detailed reviews, comparisons, and an easy-to-read analysis chart, visit our best mattresses for back pain review, where we feature our comprehensive 10-point mattress performance rating system.
Disclosure
Our review process blends actual customer feedback, comprehensive research and analysis, and insights from expert sources to create well-informed, unbiased recommendations. We independently assess each product, but to support our efforts, we participate in affiliate partnerships that allow us to continue providing valuable sleep guidance. These partnerships help us fulfill our mission to guide people toward better sleep solutions. For a complete overview, see our review process here and full disclosure here.
Our Review Process
At Sleep Examiner, we’re passionate about natural ways to reduce stress, relax the body, breathe better, and improve sleep quality. Our commitment to providing well-rounded, unbiased perspectives ensures that every recommendation is thoroughly researched, helping you discover the practices, products, and tools that can lead to a restful, pain-free night’s sleep. We’ve recently updated our 5 best mattresses for back pain and joint relief, ensuring you have the best options for enhanced comfort and support.
FEATURED REVIEWS:
Top-Rated Organic Mattresses
